Information Asymmetry in Hospitals: Evidence of the Lack of Cost Awareness in Clinicians
Abstract
Background Information asymmetries and the agency relationship are two defining features of the healthcare system. These market failures are often used as a rationale for government intervention. Many countries have government financing and provision of healthcare in order to correct for this, while health technology agencies also exist to improve efficiency. However, informational asymmetries and the resulting principal-agent problem still persist, and one example is the lack of cost awareness amongst clinicians. This study explores the cost awareness of clinicians across different settings. Methods We targeted four clinical cohorts: medical students, Senior House Officers/Interns, Mid-grade Senior Registrar/Residents, and Consultant/Attending Physicians, in six hospitals in the United Kingdom, the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Spain. The survey asked respondents to report the cost (as they recalled) of different types of scans, visits, medications and tests. Our analysis focused on the differential between the perceived/recalled cost and the actual cost. We explored variation across speciality, country and other potential confounders. Cost-awareness levels were estimated based on the cost estimates within 25% of the actual cost.Results We received 705 complete responses from six sites across five countries. Our analysis found that respondents often overestimated the cost of common tests while underestimating high-cost tests. The mean cost-awareness levels varied between 4 and 23% for different items. Respondents acknowledged that they did not feel they had received adequate training in cost awareness. Discussion The current financial climate means that cost awareness and the appropriate use of scarce healthcare resources is more paramount than perhaps ever before. Much of the focus of health economics research is on high-cost innovative technologies, yet there is considerable waste in the system with respect to overtreatment and overdiagnosis. Common reasons put forward for this include defensive medicine, poor education, clinical uncertainty and the institution of protocols.
Publication Date
2022-05-24
Publication Title
Applied Health Economics and Health Policy
ISSN
1175-5652
Embargo Period
2024-04-11
Recommended Citation
Fabes, J., Avşar, T., Spiro, J., Fernandez, T., Eilers, H., Evans, S., Hessheimer, A., Lorgelly, P., Spiro, M., Milliken, D., Morkane, C., Nettlefold, C., Xiang, P., Vogts, N., Curell, A., Torroella, A., Melia, A., Jackson, R., Hanger, M., & Poole, A. (2022) 'Information Asymmetry in Hospitals: Evidence of the Lack of Cost Awareness in Clinicians', Applied Health Economics and Health Policy, . Available at: 10.1007/s40258-022-00736-x" >https://doi.org/10.1007/s40258-022-00736-x
