Abstract
The progress of disadvantaged students has been a longstanding policy focus in schools, with the necessity of school leaders using research evidence to inform their work inherently tied to both in-school practice and the condition of government funding to support disadvantaged students. Through an ethnographic study, focusing upon the role of middle leaders, I explore how research evidence is made sense of and constructed in professional practice and then mobilised in the field. This study examines the interrelationships between middle leaders, the school, the state and the disadvantaged students that are the focus of their work.The study took place in a comprehensive secondary school in the South West of England between summer and early Autumn of 2023. Through engaging Bourdieu’s theoretical tools, I examine the ways in which research evidence is constructed in professional practice, where it is used to both construct a symbolic relationship in the field but also to support middle leaders to negotiate ideas in practice to support disadvantaged students. Through the classifications imposed upon them by the state, in which a certain type of evidence is favoured as ‘good’ evidence, teachers take up certain positions in which the workings of power are intrinsically tied to the ways in which research evidence is talked about and implemented within schools. I contend that research evidence has been given sacred status in its symbolic positioning within the schooling field. Research evidence has been legitimated to the extent that its taken for granted quality elicits acceptance and respect, being set apart as superior from other knowledge in the schooling field. A teacher’s relationship to research evidence and their leadership position are inherently linked through a symbolic relationship whereby the ‘good’ teacher and leader moves to be part of a group of social inclusion, creating distinction and contributing to their status in the field. Whilst this status offers a degree of protection from the high-stakes accountability mechanisms, it also supports teachers to have the space to enact professional practice. Consequently, the symbolic position that middle leaders take up towards research evidence allows them the space for negotiation in practice, in which they can make decisions about disadvantaged students.This study contributes to the debate regarding the role of the state in schools, as well considerations for policy makers, school leaders and teachers about the way in which research evidence can be engaged with to impact upon professional practice.
Awarding Institution(s)
University of Plymouth
Supervisor
Marie Lavelle, Peter Kelly
Document Type
Thesis
Publication Date
2026
Embargo Period
2026-11-05
Deposit Date
November 2026
DOI Link
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
Recommended Citation
Drake, R. (2026) How do teachers and middle leaders construct and mobilise ‘research’ and ‘evidence’ in their professional practice, particularly in relation to disadvantaged students?. Thesis. University of Plymouth. Available at: https://doi.org/10.24382/hsps-q597
